San Fernando Court Backs City, Upholds Water Firm's Suspension
The City of San Fernando in Pampanga has secured a significant legal victory in its ongoing dispute with PrimeWater Infrastructure Corporation. Mayor Vilma Caluag confirmed on Wednesday, December 3, 2025, that the court has denied the water distributor's petitions, allowing the city's suspension order to remain firmly in effect.
Legal Setback for PrimeWater
According to Mayor Caluag, the court rejected two key legal motions from PrimeWater: a petition for a temporary restraining order and a petition for a preliminary injunction. These petitions were aimed at blocking Executive Order No. 87, which the city government implemented on November 17, 2025. The denial by the court means the local government's decision to suspend PrimeWater's business permit stands unchallenged for now.
The mayor issued her statement following the court's decision, emphasizing the city's position. She stated that the city government remains open to any further legal steps PrimeWater might take, but affirmed that the local government unit will continue to manage the city's water utility operations in the interim.
Roots of the Suspension: Service and Standards
The suspension was not enacted lightly. Executive Order No. 87 was issued after the city hall received numerous complaints from consumers regarding poor water service. Beyond service delivery issues, the order also cites a more serious infraction: PrimeWater's alleged violation of specific provisions within the City's 2008 Environmental Code related to water quality standards.
This two-pronged rationale—failing to meet service expectations and potentially compromising environmental and health standards—formed the core of the city's legal basis for the suspension.
What Comes Next?
With the court's recent decision, the operational halt for PrimeWater in San Fernando continues indefinitely. Mayor Caluag's announcement reinforces the city's commitment to asserting its regulatory authority over essential public utilities. The ball is now in PrimeWater's court to decide its next legal or operational move. News outlet CLTV36 has reported that it is seeking comment from PrimeWater to present its side of the story.
This development highlights the escalating tension between local government units and private utility concessionaires, centering on accountability, service quality, and adherence to local ordinances. The residents of San Fernando await a permanent resolution to ensure reliable and safe water supply.
