A Filipino Man's Heart Divided Between Two Women
In a heartfelt letter published on November 14, 2025, a 46-year-old businessman named Richard reached out to popular advice columnist Noy Kulas with a common yet confusing romantic predicament. The single man finds himself emotionally attached to two different women and desperately needs guidance on which path to choose for his future.
The Two Women in Richard's Life
Richard described both women in detail, starting with Pia, a single mother in her early 30s who works as medical personnel. He characterizes her as beautiful, sexy, and kind, but has noticed significant insecurity in her behavior. Though they aren't officially in a relationship, Pia maintains constant communication through chats, texts, and calls, frequently questioning Richard about his whereabouts and companions.
The second woman, Cheny, presents a completely different dynamic. She is a young widow without children who takes a more reserved approach to their connection. Cheny rarely initiates contact through chats, texts, or calls unless Richard makes the first move. She possesses a stable supervisory position at her company and shares the qualities of being kind and attractive that Richard values.
Noy Kulas Provides Expert Relationship Guidance
The experienced columnist offered thoughtful advice that emphasized looking beyond current treatment patterns. Noy Kulas cautioned Richard against basing his decision solely on how each woman treats him at this early stage of their acquaintance. Instead, he recommended taking time to understand their true characters, particularly how they treat their families and parents.
Regarding Pia's behavior, Noy Kulas suggested that her constant communication might indicate genuine interest rather than mere insecurity. She wants to know you, he explained, noting that this pattern might naturally diminish as she becomes more comfortable in the relationship. He also acknowledged that her previous experience as a single mother who has been disappointed might contribute to her current behavior.
For Cheny's more detached approach, the columnist offered multiple interpretations. Her supervisory position demands significant energy and focus, potentially leaving little room for constant monitoring of Richard's activities. Alternatively, as a widow who has experienced loss, she might be observing whether Richard will actively pursue the relationship, or she might simply have less interest in him compared to Pia.
The final advice centered on taking sufficient time to know both women better before making any commitment. Noy Klas observed that Richard appears ready for marriage but needs clarity about which woman represents the better long-term partner for his life journey.
