Retired Justice Carpio Details Planned Discussion Points for Friendly Debate with Senator Marcoleta
Retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has publicly shared the specific topics he intends to address in a potential "friendly debate" with Senator Rodante Marcoleta. This development follows Carpio's acceptance last week of Marcoleta's challenge for such a debate, which the senator proposed before considering an invitation to visit the Kalayaan Island Group (KIG).
Background on the Debate Challenge and Invitation
Previously, Senator Marcoleta stated that he wishes to engage in a debate prior to accepting the invitation from Commodore Jay Tarriela to fly to the KIG. In response, Commodore Tarriela expressed openness to a debate but emphasized that it should be limited to light topics, asserting that the nation's rights in the West Philippine Sea must not be questioned in public discussion.
Carpio's Emphasis on Constitutional Responsibilities
Justice Carpio highlighted that while he respects the freedom of expression of some senators, he reminded them of their constitutional oath and responsibilities. He pointed out that the Constitution mandates the State to protect and conserve marine wealth within the exclusive economic zone. Carpio further noted that while personal views may be accepted, government officials must always consider their sworn duty to defend the territory of the Philippines.
This debate preparation underscores ongoing discussions about national sovereignty and the legal frameworks governing the West Philippine Sea, with key figures from the judiciary and legislative branches actively participating in the discourse.
